There was a very interesting column yesterday by the Globe & Mail's John Ibbitson on how the Republican Party can revive its sagging fortunes:
Thoughtful conservatives are in despair over the state of the GOP.
“It concerns me that the Democratic Party may not have enough worthy
adversaries in the coming years to save us from the tyranny of
sustained one-party rule,” columnist Kathleen Parker wrote recently in
the Washington Post.
“The sad thing is that President [George W.] Bush spent America into
debt, tore apart its conservative movement and left his own political
party shattered,” conservative talk-show host Joe Scarborough concludes
in a new book, The Last Best Hope .
The Republican Party, in the words of Reihan Salam, a young conservative pundit and co-author of Grand New Party , is “cocooning”: talking and listening only to itself, rather than to the broader body politic.
The conservative core blames Mr. Bush for destroying the party's
credibility by overspending. Lunatic fringers such as Rush Limbaugh and
Glenn Beck are increasingly the voice of the movement. Thoughtful
Republicans are in eclipse or on the run.
“There's a Republican Stalinism that exists,” believes Michael
Moynihan, executive editor of the libertarian Reason magazine.
“Moderates are being run out of the party.”
As a result, there's absolutely no hope that the Republicans will
take the 10 Senate seats or 40 House seats needed to recapture one of
those chambers in next year's midterm elections. And Barack Obama's
confident, competent administration will be extremely hard to bring
down in 2012.
Yet there are cracks. The President is having a hard time corralling
the more conservative members of his own party in Congress. The push
for massive and nearly simultaneous reforms in health care, the
environment and immigration could, in fact, lead to either policy
paralysis or deeply flawed legislation. The annual deficit threatens to
entrench itself at trillion-dollar levels. Unless it is brought down to
near zero, and soon, the national debt will cripple the economy.
A restored Republican Party promising fiscal reform could become
politically attractive to independents worried that the Democrats are
spending the country into ruin.
There is a Republican road to victory. To get there, the party need
only embrace a few simple principles. Herewith, five steps for reviving
the GOP.
1. Accept the Obama consensus . American federal politics
mirrors the evolutionary theory of punctuated equilibrium. For long
periods, society embraces a certain political consensus, expressed by
one dominant party. Then events send things into flux, until a new
consensus emerges.
During a period of consensus, the minority party can win government,
but only by accepting the fundamentals of that consensus. So Grover
Cleveland, a Democrat, became president by accepting the Republican
consensus in support of small government and big business that
dominated from 1860 until soon before the First World War.
Dwight Eisenhower governed as a Republican within the Franklin
Roosevelt New Deal consensus that lasted from 1932 until the late
1960s.
And Bill Clinton governed as a Democrat within the Ronald Reagan
small-government, personal-responsibility consensus that marked the
last two decades of the past century.
Events and demographics have produced a new consensus, in favour of
social reform at home accompanied by greater modesty abroad. It could
be called the Obama consensus, and for as long as it lasts, the
Republicans will be able to come to power only by accepting it.
“There is a new set of challenges” facing all politicians, believes
the conservative commentator Jonathan Roach, “and sitting around saying
‘No, no, no' and ‘Cut taxes, cut taxes, cut taxes,' was never adequate,
but now is blatantly inadequate, now that the voters have said that
didn't work under Bush and they're ready to try something different.”
This doesn't mean Republicans need to stop being conservative. There
are smaller-government solutions to global warming. Conservatives can
embrace education or health-care reform, while insisting that personal
choice should trump statist fiats. “You need more subtlety to the
small-government, or to the cheap-but-effective government, message,”
Mr. Salam argues.
The better line of reasoning is to accept that “the left has been
right in diagnosing problem X, Y or Z, but their solution is wrong.”
Once the Republicans acknowledge the new consensus, it will be easier for them to embrace the second principle.
2. Love cities . Take a look at the map below.
It was prepared by Mark Newman, of the University of Michigan. It
represents the 2008 electoral-college vote, with the states shrunken or
enlarged to reflect their population. Republican victories (shown in
grey) were mostly limited to states in the South and the High Plains.
With a few exceptions, the Republican message of tax cuts and social
conservatism plays well only in small, mostly rural states that are
growing slowly, if at all. Alabama. Mississippi. Wyoming. Oklahoma.
“Unless North Dakota suddenly gets 54 electoral votes, would someone
please show me another way for Republicans to realistically conclude we
can compete at the national level?” conservative commentator and
Republican operative Bill Greener lamented on Salon.com.
In the United States, as in Canada, population is flowing from rural
to urban. Consider Texas. According to a recent report by Susan Combs,
the state's Comptroller for Public Accounts, 93 rural counties are
experiencing population declines. But between 2000 and 2005, the
population in the urban centres increased by at least 20 per cent.
The rural-to-urban shift is one demographic reason why Democrats are
increasingly confident that Texas will soon belong to them. There's
another. The Republicans will lose Texas, along with every presidential
election, unless they learn to:
3. Love minorities . African-Americans constituted 13 per cent
of the vote last November. More than 90 per cent of them voted for Mr.
Obama. Latinos made up 9 per cent of the vote. They voted better than
two-to-one for the Democrats. And that was before white, male
Republican senators spent a week grilling the Supreme Court nominee
Sonia Sotomayor over her “wise Latina” comments.
“The swing voters are Hispanic voters in most of the swing states,”
former Florida governor Jeb Bush said in a recent Esquire interview.
“And Republicans have done a poor job, sending signals that Hispanics
aren't wanted in our party. Which is bizarre.”
Take Texas again. According to the Office of the State Demographer,
the Latino population will surpass the non-Hispanic white population in
Texas within 10 years. In 2040, whites will make up less than a third
of the state's population. No wonder the Democrats are so certain Texas
is trending their way.
John McCain won the white vote nationally by 56 to 43 per cent. But
white voters don't elect presidents. Ethnic minorities, voting en bloc,
do. And there's another bloc out there, which is why Republicans must
also learn to:
4. Love the young . The Obama consensus didn't emerge from a
sudden change of heart among Boomers and Gen-Xers. It emerged because
voters under 30 surged to the polls in support of Mr. Obama's agenda.
Millennials (those born between roughly 1978 and 2000) cast about 18
per cent of the vote, and two-thirds of them voted Democrat. In 2012,
one voter in four will be a millennial. They are why the GOP simply
must abandon social conservatism to return to power.
A recent poll from the liberal-but-fair Center for American Progress
revealed that 58 per cent of millennials support gay marriage. And 64
per cent agreed with the statement “religious faith should focus more
on promoting tolerance, social justice and peace in society, and less
on opposing abortion or gay rights,” while only 19 per cent disagreed.
And no, people don't become more conservative as they age. Repeated
studies have shown that people keep their core values with them through
life.
“The culture wars are over,” Mr. Moynihan believes. “The rank and
file of the Republican Party just don't know it.” It's time someone
told them.
If the leadership of the Republican Party is able to accept and act
on these four principles, then it will be ready to embrace the fifth,
the most important of all.
5. Be creative . Conservatives believe that the best way to
preserve individual freedom is for government to be no larger, and
taxes no higher, than absolutely necessary. But there are problems for
which simply cutting taxes is not a solution. Republicans need to think
clearly and creatively about health care, education, the environment,
immigration, regulatory reform. They need to work with Democrats where
possible, to show the party is on the side of getting things done, not
just getting in the way.
All of the above will happen, just as soon as Republicans get tired
of losing elections and watching formerly reliable states – Virginia,
North Carolina, Colorado, New Mexico – switch to the Democrats. Hello,
Texas.
The depressing news is that, right now, the ravers are in charge.
There are a lot of them. Two of the top five books on the New York
Times bestseller list are conservative screeds; Fox News is beating the
competition two-to-one.
But the ravers are not the majority; they are an exercised minority.
They are far fewer than the self-identified independents, who now
outnumber registered Democrats and who far, far outnumber registered
Republicans.
“The Republican Party is a zombie party,” Mr. Roach believes. “The
defining characteristic of a zombie party is an inability to learn, to
keep trying the same failed approaches, and consider it a virtue.”
Of course the Republicans could simply wait for the consensus to
shift back in their favour. If history is any guide that's bound to
happen, a generation or two from now.
Ibbitson five-step recipe adds up to one
thing: bye-bye Sarah, but then again, there's a reason Carbiou Barbie
remains my very favourite Republican and it is this: her nomination as the 2012 nominee would guarantee Obama's reelection and give him (and the world) four more years to repair the profound damage cause by the most incompetent malevolent Administration in history. However, I don't think this will come to pass because the election cycle resumes, the GOP will realize she's a non-starter as a mainstream candidate and she'll finish third or fourth among the candidates. Still, I'm hopeful she'll do better and maintain the GOP hegemony in all the empty states.
Recent Comments